Sunday, March 29, 2015

Ted Cruz and the American "civil religion." This guy is even scarier than we thought.

Courtesy of Salon:  

Cruz’s White House run is disturbing, and not just because it involves Ted Cruz. Rather, he embodies the modern conservative propensity toward a fundamentalist American civil religion and its attendant, overly simplistic myths. As the English political activist George Monbiot observed during the dawn of the second President Bush’s Iraq War, to America’s conservative subculture “the United States is no longer just a nation. It is now a religion… It is not just that the Americans are God’s chosen people; America itself is now perceived as a divine project.” American civil religion hinges on what Ted Cruz defined in his Liberty University speech as “the promise of America,” embodied in “the American exceptionalism that has made this nation a clarion voice for freedom in the world, a shining city on a hill.” The religion of America is a civil religion that casts the United States as a divine world power shaped by a series of comforting myths that, in the eyes of fervent believers like Cruz, make it the ultimate political Promised Land. 

The term “civil religion” goes back to the writings of French philosopher Jean Jacques Rousseau, who ruminated on the tensions that arise when church and state become separate entities. In American discourse, the term is most closely associated with sociologist Robert Bellah. In 1967, Bellah characterized civil religion as “a set of beliefs, symbols, and rituals” that was “neither sectarian nor in any specific sense Christian” but nonetheless constituted a shared experience of being American that was inspired by Christian notions of redemption and spiritual fulfillment. Civil religion casts America as a beacon of secular and sacred hope in a fallen modern world. In this context, Bellah wrote, “Europe is Egypt” and America was the Promised Land to which ”God has led his people to establish a new sort of social order that shall be a light unto all the nations.” And if this concept seems open-ended and ripe for abuse, that’s because it is. 

.......

Cruz had the myth of the Chosen Nation down pat when he claimed that America is “an indispensable nation, a unique nation in the history of the world.” As for the myth of Nature’s Nation, he evoked America as the cultivated political garden of God Himself that, “from the dawn of this country, at every stage… has enjoyed God’s providential blessing.” The myth of the Christian Nation? Cruz parroted the now standard (but historically bogus) right-wing claim that the U.S. “was founded upon” the idea that rights come from a very specific “God Almighty.” Cruz’s reference to the myth of Manifest Destiny was more veiled, but he name-dropped key historical figures such as Patrick Henry, Thomas Jefferson, Franklin Delano Roosevelt (no doubt for good bipartisan measure) and, of course, Ronald Reagan to reiterate his point that God has blessed every step in America’s development. The myth of the Capitalist Nation came via his railing against standard conservative government bogeymen like “regulators,” “tax collectors” and Obamacare that despoil the purity of the Free Market. Finally, Cruz touted the myth of the Innocent Nation when he claimed that political change will only come from “lovers of liberty” who realize that “God isn’t done with America yet.” Bless their liberty-loving souls. 

Cruz’s speech was a prime example of how the right wing promotes a deeply fundamentalist American civil religion that relies on time-honored myths to characterize the United States as a nation guided by providential destiny. Cruz and other conservatives don’t see America as one nation that is a part of world history; they see it as one nation apart from world history, one that exists free of the flawed human agency and historical contingency that — contrary to Cruz’s claims — has shaped all of the human experience. 

An America as defined by a future President Cruz is an America that sees itself as blindingly perfect, naively innocent, incapable of critical reflection over both its strengths and weaknesses and utterly convinced of its capacity to shape the world in its own image. Cruz’s version of civil religion is the ultimate example of how conservatives “absolutize the righteousness of the United States.” When you believe that God has blessed America from the beginning, you ignore the times that Americans have invoked God to justify the evils of Indian removal, slavery, racism, sexism and environmental destruction. More importantly, you undervalue the times when Americans have overcome those sins to demonstrate what Abraham Lincoln called ”the better angels of our nature.” When you worship capitalism and tout the United States as the world’s only hope, you ignore the false idols that led to the Great Recession and the bloody folly of the Iraq War that’s left the Middle East in tatters. When you develop a false sense of American innocence, you view national self-reflection as a weakness.

This of course is the same kind of thinking that allowed an arrogant pseudo Texan from a famous political family take this country to war with the idea that all the poor savages needed was a little American exceptionalism in their lives to make all of their problems simply disappear.

It's also the same mindset shared by a Mike Huckabee, Rick Santorum, Rick Perry, Bobby Jindal, and of course Sarah Palin.

In fact when Palin suggests that President Obama is trying to "fundamentally change America" this is what she is talking about. The idea that the President would try to convince Americans to climb off their high horse and recognize that we are part of a global community that can all work together toward progress rather than an oligarchy that is working to proselytize their message of political religiosity to the unsaved, frightens people of limited intellect such as Palin.

However the most dangerous thing imaginable for this country would be to return to leadership that sees this country as not only without flaws, but incapable of mistakes due to the fact that the Constitution, much like the Bible, was inspired by God and is therefore infallible. (Amendments Shamendments.)

Now if you will excuse me I have to go lie down in the fetal position for a few minutes.

54 comments:

  1. "An America as defined by a future President Cruz is an America that sees itself as blindingly perfect, naively innocent, incapable of critical reflection over both its strengths and weaknesses and utterly convinced of its capacity to shape the world in its own image."

    Cruz' mythology sounds like the plot of "Lord of the Flies". And we all know how THAT ended...

    ReplyDelete
  2. Anonymous9:12 AM

    Another example of the profound damage that religious belief systems do... institutionalizing their superiority complex. In this country, it goes hand in hand with Christians' beloved persecution complex.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Anonymous10:11 AM

      +1,000

      Delete
    2. fromthediagonal11:34 AM

      Anon @9:12 ...institutionalizing their superiority complex... perfect. They promote xenophobia in order to even more firmly implant their christian dominionist demands while claiming any and all challengers as mortal enemies who try to destroy their one-and-only word view. Historically this is nothing new, but that does not make it any less revolting.

      Delete
    3. Anonymous4:42 PM

      Think, 'Manifest Destiny.'

      dowl

      Delete
  3. hedgewytch9:27 AM

    These people are all delusional narcissists so of course, they see "their country" in the same light that they see themselves. USA must be above and better than everyone else because THEY are! Ann Rand delusional nut jobs. They should all be subjected to psychological evaluations for general competency.

    We can be glad though that Cruz will NEVER be POTUS. He keeps on opening his mouth and his truth keeps falling out and hitting the ground with a big wet splat.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Anonymous10:11 AM

      +1,000

      Delete
    2. fromthediagonal11:39 AM

      Oh Hedgewytch, I am in total agreement with: "... they should all be subject to...", because they fail general political and philosophical Competency 101 every.damn.day! The fact that they are enamored of the hapless immigrant writer Ayn Rand is proof.

      Delete
    3. Suzy Q3:48 PM

      I teach high school English in an Indiana (yea, sorry to admit that) school and I am all the time getting free mailings asking me to teach Atlas Shrugged and Ayn Rand. Don't know who the people are pushing that agenda but they say in their mailer that they will pay for all the books needed. The mailings go straight to file 13. Talk about indoctrination or brainwashing! Sheesh!

      Delete
  4. Caroll Thompson9:34 AM

    What a load of diarrhea that is. That is the only way I can truly describe this load of bullshit.

    I would state for the record that America is not a Christian nation, has never been a Christian nation and as long as I breathe air, will never be a Christian nation. We are a nation with many religions and many citizens who chose to have no religion.

    How do I know this? Because I know my personal history. I am a direct descendant of Aquilla Chase who got off the boat in 1630. Aquilla was no Christian. He, his wife and his wife's brother were once arrested for selling peas on a Sunday (oh the horror).

    But one doesn't have to go beyond the Mayflower to see that we have always had our differences concerning religious matters. John Billington and family were on the Mayflower. John was the first man hanged in Plymouth Colony in 1630. He and his family had no use for the church folks and of course that brought him trouble with some members of the community.

    Anyway, I have known a man named Scott Billington for many years now. Scott is a direct descendant of John, and believe me, the apple didn't fall far from that tree. Talking to Scott is like going back in time. He can tell you the entire family history and no Billington was ever what you might call a Christian.

    A lot of sons and the daughters of the old names are here in New England and especially in Maine (where people keep moving out, not moving in). Once upon a time when we still had phone books, you could look up the names and it wasn't much different from the names of any revolutionary roll call.

    There are many names of people who are not Christians, have never Christians and while breathing free air, will not let the religious right hijack our Country the way they have hijacked the Republican Party.

    The news from our next door neighbor New Hampshire is that the R's down there think Cruz is a loser. New Hampshire is the Live Free or Die State. We are not free if religion finds its way into our Government.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Anonymous10:51 AM

      Every study out there shows that fewer and fewer people are following an organized religion, and the number of atheists is growing. And yet there is a small but zealous, loud, and powerful minority of faux christians who are seizing more and more control of our government.

      It's actually quite frightening for those of us who fervently believe in the separation of church and state.

      Delete
  5. Anonymous9:46 AM

    Cruz is talking like that so he can become the Jesus of America.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Anonymous10:49 AM

      HIs father anointed him to be the Saviour/King of America.

      Delete
    2. SallyinMI12:05 PM

      And Daddy will funnel all the money in America into the church they will run together...Seven Mountains Completed.

      Delete
    3. Anonymous4:49 PM

      Yes! The pseudo-christiany dominionist theocrats who claim world power (and wealth), now.

      dowl

      Delete
  6. "It's also the same mindset shared by a Mike Huckabee, Rick Santorum, Rick Perry, Bobby Jindal, and of course Sarah Palin"
    -----------------------------------
    I am not so sure of that in regard to Palin. I have seen no evidence that she cares the slightest bit about anything except herself. She is also too damn stupid and lazy to have actually studied any of the (for want of a better word) philosophy that has shaped the mindset of a Cruz or Huckabee.

    All of her prattling is nothing but all the words strung together that she has found will get her attention and/or money. I think she is willing to use the religious beliefs of others if they serve her. She will play along, as with the cultists at c4p, but there is no way in the world that malignant narcissist sees herself as a subject commanded to obey Someone greater than she.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Anonymous10:58 AM

      Absolutely! It is all about Sarah with Sarah. She cares not a whit about anything but money and attention. It is all about how she can leverage current events and beliefs to her benefit. She is a tiny air-headed dollop of shit.

      Delete
  7. Anonymous10:01 AM

    9:47 AM No one is even talking about Sarah Palin anymore. What an enjoyment and slice of heaven!

    ReplyDelete
  8. Anonymous10:03 AM

    I'm glad the article and also Gryphen's response correctly and accurately did NOT equate this "civil religion" that extremists like Cruz want, to Christianity, because this "civil religion" is anything but. Unlike the "Love your neighbor as yourself" of Christianity, the evil religion from Hell that Cruz, Palin, et al espouse is more like, "Kill your neighbor as you would yourself, if you had PTSD." It is a religion of hate, war, bigotry, and racism. It is anything BUT Christianity. These war-mongering liars co-opt the term "Christianity" and wrongfully apply to their hateful civil religion, to add to their long list of lies, crimes, and misdeeds. Hell, these people glory in their sins.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. fromthediagonal11:43 AM

      Well said, anon@10:03! Keep going!

      Delete
  9. Anonymous10:04 AM

    THE CLOWN CAR OF REPUBLICANS: Ted Cruz, Lindsey Graham, Scott Walker, Jeb Bush, Paul Rand and Donald Trump!

    Voting for Hillary Clinton is not going to be difficult! Can hardly wait to cast my ballot!

    ReplyDelete
  10. Anonymous10:13 AM

    Palin is not a Christian; she just plays one on TV. Ditto for Cruz.

    They love hate and war, not love and peace.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Anonymous5:20 PM

      both palin and cruz seek out darkness instead of Light.

      Delete
  11. In 1958 George Wallace lost his bid for Governor of Alabama. After the election, aide Seymore Trammell recalled Wallace saying, "Seymore, you know why I lost that governor's race? ... I was outniggered by John Patterson. And I'll tell you here and now, I will never be outniggered again."[Wikipedia]

    I see Ted Cruz as just as calculating and just as dangerous, wrapping himself in an ideology of "Christian" entitlement in order to amass personal power and personal wealth and to persecute all Americans except the privileged few.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Anonymous11:05 AM

      Cruz is such a creepy looking guy too! Evil inside and out! Assuredly not a Christian! He leads the 'nasty' in the Republican/Tea Party movement!

      Delete
  12. OT: Martin O'Malley "The Presidency of the U.S. Is Not Some Crown to Be Passed Between Two Families"

    http://www.weeklystandard.com/blogs/omalley-presidency-us-not-some-crown-be-passed-between-two-families_902431.html

    ReplyDelete
  13. Anonymous10:36 AM

    Salon lol. Sure whatever.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Anonymous10:49 AM

      Spoken like Sarah.

      Delete
  14. London Bridges10:42 AM

    I finally figured out Ted Cruz's doppleganger, and it is very scary:
    Cruz looks exactly like ventriloquist dummy, Jerry Mahoney. Very fitting as Cruz is spewing nonsense on behalf of some "sponsor," exactly like Mahoney.
    http://www.bing.com/images/search?q=jerry+mahoney+ventriloquist+dummy+pictures&qpvt=jerry+mahoney+ventriloquist+dummy+pictures&qpvt=jerry+mahoney+ventriloquist+dummy+pictures&FORM=IGRE#view=detail&i

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Anonymous11:09 AM

      He has dark hallow eyes and mouth, he is HALLOW with something or someone stuck up his Fucking ASShole.
      Fuck u Sarah Palin..
      Remember that it started decades ago with bullshit from way more powerful white FUCKS, generations ago in this country filled with bigotry and with total lack of empathy for others.

      Delete
  15. Anonymous11:19 AM

    By asking straightforward and direct questions, ABC’s George Stephanopoulos crushed Gov. Mike Pence’s facade that his legalized discrimination bill is about ‘religious freedom.’

    Video:

    http://www.politicususa.com/2015/03/29/abcs-george-stephanopoulos-crushes-gov-mike-pences-religious-freedom-facade.html

    Now Gov. Pence is reduced to lamely complaining that his and the legislatures efforts have been misunderstood or distorted. "I just can’t account for the hostility that’s been directed at our state,” Pence told the Indianapolis Star. “I’ve been taken aback by the mischaracterizations from outside the state of Indiana about what is in this bill.” He can't even manage the standard, conservatives in my state are being victimized by the axis of gays and liberals. He seems genuinely surprised.

    http://talkingpointsmemo.com/edblog/somebody-didnt-see-that-coming

    Indiana is going to hell with this absolute and utter discrimination and Pence is leading the parade.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. SallyinMI12:03 PM

      Well, I guess he's no longer on the GOP short list for POTUS, huh?

      Delete
  16. Anonymous11:23 AM

    Watch "Park Avenue," a documentary on Netflix.

    ReplyDelete
  17. Anonymous11:26 AM

    He's a cross between Jerry Mahoney and Knucklehead Smith and Charlie Manson.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. SallyinMI12:02 PM

      And Charlie McCarthy, sans the intelligence of Edgar Bergen.

      Delete
  18. Anonymous11:38 AM

    http://www.nytimes.com/2015/03/16/us/evangelicals-aim-to-mobilize-an-army-for-republicans-in-2016.html?ref=politics&_r=1

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Anonymous5:27 PM

      Now that's some scary shit!

      Delete
  19. Anonymous11:41 AM

    "... the idea that all the poor savages needed was a little American exceptionalism in their lives to make all of their problems simply disappear."

    This is the same thinking that produces

    "...the idea that all raped women need to submit to birthing a baby to make all of their problems simply disappear."

    ReplyDelete
  20. Anonymous11:43 AM

    Tonight, HBO is showing for the first time a documentary, 'Going Clear: Scientology and the Prison Of Belief.'

    It is my opinion that there are a lot more 'Prisons' than just Scientology and other cults...I think what is described in the Salon article as 'civil religion' is another one.

    It seems a certain segment of the American population is very susceptible to these 'Prisons'...they enter them willingly and are loathe to leave them once the doors are pointed out to them...something very poignantly described in the documentary...

    ...something we all should examine in our own lives, perhaps?


    ReplyDelete
  21. London Bridges11:56 AM

    This movie perfectly describes the emergence of the batsh*t republicans taking over Congress. The inmates have taken over the institution. Chopping (services, etc.) therapy.
    https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=UNHNFvLyTzg
    Watch the first 10 minutes at minimum. Don't look in the basement!

    ReplyDelete
  22. Anonymous11:58 AM

    Not just the Fundies & Dominionists. This notion that America is a sacred entity is pretty much Mormon Doctrine from the get go.

    ReplyDelete
  23. Anonymous12:03 PM

    Cruz made his fundamentalist and dominionist views known during his campaign for the Senate.

    His political mentor was Paul Weyrich whose stated goal was to destroy our democratic institutions and who recruited Jerry Falwell and other fundamentalist christian leaders to form the Moral Majority and other religious-political organizations.

    Interesting that Cruz chose Falwell's Liberty University to launch his campaign for the GOP presidential nomination.

    ReplyDelete
  24. Anonymous12:04 PM

    So which religion is, exactly, this American religion?

    Just for starters: the Pope, and Roman Catholic bishops, strongly oppose the death penalty. The sanctity of life works at both ends, they say. But....they're Christians!

    But rabid evangelicals are thirsty for the blood of all those they think are beneath them. They think they're the only legitimate
    "Christians."

    That's a stark a difference as can be imagined. Which is right?

    btw -- the KKK hates the Roman Catholic church, and always has. Don't fool yourself. Catholics -- immigrants from Italy and Ireland, for example -- were to be condemned and persecuted as non-Aryan immigrants. Go back 100 years and see what they said about those foreigners. That fed into American isolationism -- don't go fight foreign wars for the benefit of those furreners. It kept us out of WWI and WWII for several years after we could have been fighting overseas.

    Now the Tea Party has turned it on its head -- go off and fight wars overseas. They just have a new enemy to use for their purposes.

    ReplyDelete
  25. Anonymous12:12 PM

    The religion of our nation was explicitly laid out by our forefathers...

    Amendment I
    "Congress shall make no law respecting an establishment of religion, or prohibiting the free exercise thereof; or abridging the freedom of speech, or of the press; or the right of the people peaceably to assemble, and to petition the Government for a redress of grievances."

    Now if only we can get these Regressive Party Buffoons to open and read that Pocket Guide of The United States Constitution that they wave about the world will be a much safer place.

    The Nationalism they are promoting hasn't worked well anywhere it has been attempted. The world tends to rise up against every attempt and we are on the verge of standing alone.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Suzy Q5:54 PM

      Yea, 12:12, I noticed Saudi Arabia is forming their own army because they don't trust us anymore on account of we're dealing with Iran. Thanks Tehran Tommy and those other 46 traitors for putting those ideas out there to the world that the US can't be trusted. The Republicans will steal the '16 election. The Kochs will not be denied with all the money that they are ponying up.

      Delete
  26. Anonymous12:36 PM

    Cruz's job is to start the GOP's ball rolling, steer the debate as far ridiculous right as possible, and get the knuckledragggers on board with a bone they can continue to suckle until the voting booth where they will be instructed to vote for the only remaining
    GOP candidate (Bush?).
    It's a strategically orchestrated roll-out by Rove et al., funded by Kochs et al.
    Put your checkerboard away, this is chess.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Anonymous8:47 PM

      Not chess, Chutes and Ladders, maybe? Candy Land?

      dowl

      Delete
  27. Anonymous2:18 PM

    Americans as a whole are no more "exceptional" than those of other countries. Individual exceptionalism is achieved, not a birthright. A country settled by massacring its native people, built on slave labor, exercising racism, and becoming a war monger, is hardly a beacon of light. We do not rank highest in education, quality of life, healthcare, longevity, per capita income...
    Like many undereducated neighborhood bullies, we think we are better than everyone else, with no self awareness.

    ReplyDelete
  28. Randall2:20 PM

    Whatever "grace" and "exceptionalism" that might have been provided to this nation by "Providence" was forfeited when the GW Bush regime TORTURED HUMAN BEINGS

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Suzy Q3:30 PM

      And then NOTHING happened to the war criminals Bush, Cheney, Rove, Libby, Rumsfeld, Wolfowitz, et al. All of them should have been tried at the Hague, convicted and hanged! It was a BIG Mistake that Nancy Pelosi made when she said Congress was looking forward and wouldn't be looking back at any mistakes that may have been made by the previous administration. (Had they done that everyone who voted for the war would have been guilty so couldn't have that.). I thought that was nuts then and still do. And then the Republicans have the NERVE to blame ISIS on Obama!! Those 47 Republican traitors should be sent to Guantanamo and tortured for their poor judgement as well. American exceptionalism! What an effing joke!

      Delete
  29. Anonymous2:38 PM

    He's every bit as scary as I had imagined..........I find very little comfort in that fact.......

    ReplyDelete
  30. Anonymous4:14 PM

    His pappasita is a preacher, and he learned all the red meat phrases, the tone and movements of a preacher in church to kiss the fundamentalist's asses till their eyelids flutter. The first inkling of this entire mixing of religion and government I saw coming the first time President GWBush said the words "Faith based initiatives". And today's menu of religiofascists give me the same chill. I wonder if they defend the Muslim religion, eastern religions, etc with the same fervor as christians?

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Anonymous9:59 PM

      You are joking about them defending the Muslim and Eastern Religions aren't you?

      Delete
  31. Anonymous7:28 PM

    The more I see of Cruz the more I like him. He is like a breathe of fresh air on the political landscape to revive America again.

    ReplyDelete

Don't feed the trolls!
It just goes directly to their thighs.